White walls went up along Tambo Bridge in Parañaque ahead of the 49th ASEAN Summit. Some residents saw them as a way to hide poverty from visiting delegates. I think they had every reason to ask what the government wanted its guests to see.
The people living beside the Estero de Tripa de Gallina had different things to say about those walls. One older resident told the Daily Tribune he was fine with them. He saw little point in letting visitors look down on a waterway full of garbage, and he said the barriers left access to nearby homes open. Other residents wondered why the authorities had gone to the trouble of covering the estero when they could have cleaned it. I can understand both reactions. Anyone who has had guests coming knows the urge to tidy up. The woman who wanted the estero cleaned was asking for something that would still matter the morning after the visitors left.

Then there was the Facebook story about Malacañang ordering a velvet curtain 50 kilometers long and 80 stories high. VERA Files traced it to a satirical post that some readers had taken literally. The dimensions are indeed impossible. What stayed with me was how readily some people believed the premise. I hear an old suspicion in that reaction. Filipinos have seen enough hurried preparations for important visitors to wonder why the same streets can spend so much of the year waiting for ordinary attention.
As a painter, I was especially bothered by the use of art in the preparations. Along J.W. Diokno Boulevard in Pasay, reproductions of works by Filipino artists appeared on roadside barriers. Among them was a work by Vicente Manansala, whose Madonna of the Slums gave a mother and child in a poor neighborhood the attention usually reserved for grander subjects. I find it a strange tribute to hang a Manansala along a route where the very people he made room for in Philippine painting could be screened from view.

In Baclaran, the cost of preparing for the summit could be measured in days without sales. The government cited security arrangements for the temporary closures and distributed P10,000 and family food packs to 1,462 affected vendors in Parañaque on November 12. One beneficiary told the Palace that the money would help with her grandchildren’s daily expenses, including those of a nursing student doing hospital duty. Her answer gives the official phrase lost income a plain meaning. A stall closes, and somewhere in the family a student’s allowance has to come from somewhere else.

Bishop Gerry Alminaza of Caritas Philippines asked who the gathering and the development around it were really for. I would put that question to the people who draw up the route maps and decide which businesses must close. At what point do the vendors get to say how many days they can afford to lose or where they might sell in the meantime? I would trust a plan more if the people expected to make room for it had a say while there was still time to change it.

I take pride in seeing the Philippines receive its neighbors well. I would take greater pride in hearing our officials tell those neighbors what families along our waterways are up against and ask what has worked in cities facing similar problems. How do they keep waterways clear when homes crowd the banks? How do they improve housing while keeping people close enough to their jobs to earn a living? Those are conversations I would gladly see our country lead. The people of Tambo have already given officials a place to begin.

When the last convoy has crossed Tambo Bridge, I would like the city officials who helped prepare for the summit to go back on foot. The residents who defended the walls and those who would have preferred a cleanup both have a stake in what happens to that stretch of water. I’d start by asking them where the garbage keeps collecting and who comes to clear it. Then I’d give them a date for the next cleanup and a name to call when the crew fails to show.